Rev. Bougher served as the pastor from 1974-1981 and from 1986-2006. On October 4, 2009, he was presented with the title of Pastor Emeritus of the church. He served with a passion for the Gospel of Jesus Christ, a love of history, and a heart for the people placed in his care. He walked alongside this congregation in times of joy, and also times of heartache, speaking wisdom along the way. Phil and his wife Pat are active Covenant Partners of the church and still share their talents and wisdom with the Covenant Partners.

Tim Davis is the Choir Director and Worship Accompanist. Tim is a freelance musician, piano instructor, and worship accompanist currently living in the Central Ohio area. He has an extensive array of experience in keyboard performance, teaching (piano and trumpet), and choir direction. He spent ten years in a boy's choir that traveled extensively throughout the United States and has toured the world as musical director of The Ink Spots. Tim currently teaches piano to a number of students in the Columbus area and has taught at the university level. He is the first call local keyboard player for all Broadway tours coming through Columbus and Dayton and has played for numerous stars, most notably Andrea Bocelli. Tim has been involved in music for worship for about as long as he can remember and has served as choral director, music director, accompanist, and arranger for many churches in the Central Ohio area. He got his start serving at Trinity United Methodist Church in Lima, Ohio, where his mom served as a pianist from 1954 until her death in 2014.